Re: Field Day log checking

Tom Schaefer NY4I

Without this devolving into the obvious taking of sides, my answer to that is that Field Day is a communications exercise up until the first contact. If your intention is to show you can setup antennas and radios in a field—running on emergency power--and make an HF contact, then after that first contact, you have proved the point. Everything after that is a contest.

But seriously, it can be both. We use skills to setup and help foster new operators to pickup contesting. I suspect I am not the only one that started contesting because of Field Day. So while I understand it is a communications exercise, it is a bit disingenuous to not also call it a contest as there is that part of it (otherwise why do we have different points for CW/Digital and phone). As with far too many things in amateur radio, we seem to always want to paint things as either/or versus with the plurality of a communications exercise/contest.

Tom NY4I

On Nov 8, 2019, at 2:42 PM, Gilbert Baron <w0mn00@...> wrote:

Not a contest in rules only. What a joke! Everybody else certainly acts as though it were. 
Outlook Laptop Gil W0MN
Hierro Candente Batir de Repente
44.08226N 92.51265 W en34rb
From: ARRL-Contesting@... <ARRL-Contesting@...> On Behalf Of Tom Schaefer NY4I
Sent: Friday, November 8, 2019 13:28
To: ARRL-Contesting@...
Subject: Re: [ARRL-Contesting] Field Day log checking
Thanks I never knew that. I will not pay any attention to the top ten then as that is not checked so really valid.
I also added wrong so the score in QST is exactly what I submitted including bonus points).
Tom NY4I

On Nov 8, 2019, at 2:16 PM, Bart Jahnke <w9jj@...> wrote:
Hello Tom,
Thanks for asking.
Field Day is not a contest (it’s a communications exercise), and as such it is not adjudicated (so there is no log checking).
I’ll email you separately regarding the scoring.
Thanks for participating!
Bart Jahnke, W9JJ
Radiosport and Field Services Manager
ARRL - The national association for Amateur Radio®
225 Main Street
Newington CT 06111-1400
Telephone: 860-594-0272
Fax: 860-594-0346
From: ARRL-Contesting@... <ARRL-Contesting@...> On Behalf Of Tom Schaefer NY4I
Sent: Friday, November 8, 2019 2:10 PM
To: ARRL-Contesting@...
Subject: [ARRL-Contesting] Field Day log checking
Reading the 2019 Field Day results, something just occurred to me. The QSOs we submitted were 1078. In the listing for W4TA (3A), I see 1078 listed in the QSOs column. While I would hope we were that accurate, that is just not likely at all.

Is the number in the results the submitted number of QSOs or the corrected number after log checking? Is a Log Checking Report possible for Field Day? 

Our score is 200 less than I expected but since it is exactly 200 less, that seems more likely a bonus point issue than any score reductions. It would be nice to know what bonus points were disallowed or what led to the score reduction so if I made an error, I do not repeat it again.

I ask as if the QSOs counts are not log checked, that sort of negates any reason to print a top ten score box (page one of the article). If this is not checked like a contest (since this is most definitely, 100% not a contest), why do we put the Top 10 score.

And for those just waiting to pounce...sure, Field Day is not a contest, OK. But we do have points and all so I am curious about the listing.


Tom NY4I 

Join to automatically receive all group messages.