toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Remember the bill was just the authorization for the FCC to write rules allowing amateur radio antennas, Authority the FCC said in PRB that they did not have.
In the past amateur Bill, the HOAs would be required by the FCC rules to let hams have effective antennas. So basically the HOA could not say no even though they had to give approval.
The big issue the HOAs had with OTARD was residents could put up a satellite/TV antenna and the first the HOA would know was when they walked by the house.
On Oct 27, 2020, at 12:40, Bob AF9W <af9w@...> wrote:
Yes, they have talked to the National HOA, they are the leading opponent to the act.
They have also discussed this with the FCC, but the FCC says it is not their call until Congress acts.
If you live in an HOA then you need to convince them that emergency communications are good for the HOA.
Then you need to show them that antennas can be erected in such a way as to not interfere with the neighbors view of the world.
In AZ I made my wire antennas out of The Wireman’s 534-Antenna Wire, 26 AWG Copper-Clad Steel Stranded Jacketed antenna wire.
It’s virtually invisible but handles 100watts with no problem.
I had my antenna up for 10 years and no problems in an HOA that
strictly forbid ham antennas. The problem is that people who live in HOA’s picture ham antennas as 70’ towers with lots of aluminum.
One of the problems with passing the law is that the National HOA verbally agreed to a deal where antennas would be allowed
but they had to be approved by the HOA and the amateur community didn’t want that.
Much unreasonableness on both sides.
From: ARRL-Antenna-Law-and-Policy@... <ARRL-Antenna-Law-and-Policy@...>
On Behalf Of Ray
Sent: Tuesday, October 27, 2020 10:28 AM
Subject: Re: [ARRL-Antenna-Law-and-Policy] Private land-Use Restrictions
Have they talked to the HOA National about this? Are they having discussions with FCC?
On Oct 27, 2020, at 08:39, Mike Polom <wa8vms@...> wrote:
I received this email in late March from my ARRL Division Director:
"The exact verbiage is still embargoed, pending fine tuning, but here is a synopsis.
1. Legislation which would pass a PRB-1 type exclusion for amateur antennas in HOAs.
2. Legislation which would allow limited amateur antennas in HOAs as an amendment to the OTARD (over the air reception
3. State driven legislation modeled after the flagpole laws and (in Florida) the garden and clothesline
Subsequently, there was a report out by the Legislative Advocacy Committee at the July ARRL BoD Meeting. The summary of that report out is as follows.
Mr. Tiemstra shared highlights of the report, calling attention to the appendix submitted that
morning which included outcomes of their meeting with Connecticut Senator Richard Blumenthal. He also provided a summary of their work on addressing private land use restrictions, noting the need to address this matter has only grown since it was introduced,
adding that they have been meeting at least once a month, have had numerous exchanges with legislators on Capitol Hill, noting that the pandemic has prevented in-person meetings and has slowed their agenda. He added that their messaging is more successful
when they define amateur radio as critical infrastructure of emergency service, which is front of mind right now. There was a discussion of the support that our efforts currently have in Washington and moving as quickly as possible on finding co-sponsors;
at this time we cannot guarantee the success of anything, but we must continue to maintain a presence and cultivate friendly relationships in order to meet our goals.
There was a also discussion about providing talking points for Board members to use in talking to members about the HOA issue, as well as an ARRL guide for members to use in negotiating tactics on antenna use restrictions with their HOA’s, as our members expect
the League to be actively working on these issues, which the Board concurred would be beneficial for all.
The actual report has not been posted to the ARRL Committee Reports website. On September 11, 2020 I emailed N6JAT,
N4MB and KG4JSZ requesting a copy of the whole report and, to date, I have received no reply from any of them.
As far as I can tell, no substantive progress has been made on this issue in the ~10 years it's been a priority at the ARRL.